Wordcraft Community Home Page
Alive or dead?

This topic can be found at:
https://wordcraft.infopop.cc/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/932607094/m/1030081386

June 08, 2016, 18:42
<Proofreader>
Alive or dead?
During discussion about fossils, a lecturersaid "Fossils live in rocky strata..." and later, "These rocks live in shale deposits..."

How can an inanimate object "live" anywhere? Shouldn't "live" be limited to beings having at least a minimum vital force?
June 08, 2016, 19:02
BobHale
I have no problem with this. I say things (and you probably do too!) like "The scissors live in the drawer." or "Don't leave your pencils all over the table, they live in the box."

A secondary use of "live" - in British English anyway - is to be usually kept or found in a particular place.


"No man but a blockhead ever wrote except for money." Samuel Johnson.
June 08, 2016, 20:09
goofy
From Beowulf:
Hi..forleton eorla gestreon eorðan healdan, gold on greote, þær hit nu gen lifað eldum swa unnyt swa hyt [æro]r wæs.

"They... let the ground hold the treasure of earls, gold in the earth, where ever it lives useless to men as of yore it was."
June 08, 2016, 20:58
Kalleh
Great quote, Goofy. I don't hear "live" used like that. I wonder if this use is a regional difference.
June 09, 2016, 05:10
<Proofreader>
I've checked two or three dics and can't find this usage. Can antuone cite it?
June 09, 2016, 05:27
goofy
https://wordcraft.infopop.cc/ev...90104806?r=141109806
June 09, 2016, 12:34
<Proofreader>
How am I supposed to remember something so long in the past. It's only noon and I can't recall if I had breakfast.
June 09, 2016, 18:38
BobHale
quote:
Originally posted by Proofreader:
I've checked two or three dics and can't find this usage. Can antuone cite it?


It's right there on the front page of a onelook search


"No man but a blockhead ever wrote except for money." Samuel Johnson.
June 22, 2016, 20:12
Kalleh
I know I am not timely in answering this, but first of all, I don't think in the U.S. we use "live" that way. Second of all, it wasn't clear at all to me that it was on the first page of Onelook. I went through all their verb definitions, and you had to push the envelope a little for that one, unless of course I missed something.