quote:

My thought follows what I've often read about EGT (explicit grammar teaching), that a little learning can be dangerous. The absurd rules taught serve only to confuse people who ordinarily speak English just fine (finely??? - see what I mean?)...Right now I'm reading John McWhorter's Word On the Street, an excellent treatment of the problems with Prescriptivism. It's not that we should not teach Standard English, it's how we do and what we teach - good writing or goofy grammar shibboleths from the 18th century, which is what most people think of when they hear the word 'grammar'