Well folks, here are the limericks and, sadly, I have completely forgotten how to post a poll (it's certainly not intuitive) so I'll just have to hope this has worked - or someone else can sort the damn thing out...
Richard English
Posts: 8038 | Location: Partridge Green, West Sussex, UK
I know it's too late to garner any votes, but I've got the winner right here:
A woman from round Upper Dicker, So her man could get up 'er slicker, Would grease up his pole Which worked on the whole - Except when it made him come quicker.This message has been edited. Last edited by: Greg S,
Looking good. I've not voted yet myself (because I know the names of the contestants) but I will do so if there's a tie. Thus far the result's looking pretty clear.
Richard English
Posts: 8038 | Location: Partridge Green, West Sussex, UK
A virginal lass (Upper Dicker) Found no man there was willing to sticker. So one day after supper She departed from Upper And in Lower, the whole town did pricker.
Well, the votes are in and limerick 6 is a clear winner written by...Greg S.
The other limericks were:
Number 1 - Mike Number 2 - Mike Number 3 - Greg S Number 4 - Kalleh Number 5 - Proofreader
My personal preference was Number 1, with its nice alliteration in L3. Greg's number six was marred for me by the faulty rhyme in L3/4. But they were all very good and so it's now over to Greg for the next destination. I won't be around for three weeks - unless I can find a computer to borrow in Canada.
Richard English
Posts: 8038 | Location: Partridge Green, West Sussex, UK
Good to see Mike back in the game, but where were Bob, Arnie, Stella and Richard (you should have put one in - it probably would have won)? I voted for Kalleh's which I really liked, but my favourite was actually the one I submitted after the event, especially after Proof improved it.
I will open a new thread shortly for the next game, which will be based around the second biggest city in the State of Victoria, behind our capital Melbourne, which is the city of Geelong.
I didn't think it would be right for me to submit an entry for my own destination. And in any case, had I won I'd have not been around for a while to sort out the new one.
Richard English
Posts: 8038 | Location: Partridge Green, West Sussex, UK
Unlike some others I find writing limericks very difficult and the results are rarely good enough to enter, let alone win. On the rare occasions that my muse visits I might send in an entry, but I can't be included in the same sentence as Bob, Stella, and Richard.
Build a man a fire and he's warm for a day. Set a man on fire and he's warm for the rest of his life.
I know you wont see this until you get back from Canada, but I'd appreciate your comments when you get back. I understand your dissatisfaction with my imperfect line 3/4 rhyme, and was just wondering if the following minor variation, which is technically no different but works aurally is technically acceptable as a properly formed limerick or not:
A young lad who roamed Upper Dicker Caused a Mum and her daughter to bicker: "But Mum, he's so cute!" "Sweetie I've heard his flute's The town's Number 1 Cherry picker."
I'm not sure what Richard's response would be, but I am guessing that his objection was not to the word Darling , but to the imperfect rhyme of cute and flute's. The easiest fix would be to move the 's to the beginning of line 5:
A young lad who roamed Upper Dicker Caused a Mum and her daughter to bicker: "But Mum, he's so cute!" "Darling I've heard his flute Is the town's Number 1 Cherry picker."
A young lad who roamed Upper Dicker Caused a Mum and her daughter to bicker: "Honey, dn't let his flute Anywhere near your chute Or he'll tell all the boys and they'll snicker."."
I have managed to get the use of a computer in Canada. And yes, the objection to the L3/4 rhymes were solely cute/flute's. My solution would simply have been to get rid of the apostrophe s and but the verb "is" into L5.
If I get a chance I'll look back later.
Richard English
Posts: 8038 | Location: Partridge Green, West Sussex, UK